Skip to content

Ontario budget: Throwing money at problems they helped to create says Fedeli

'The finance minister re-committed in November that his government would balance the budget this year. Now we are learning that instead, there will be a $6.7 billion deficit'
queens park inside chamber shutterstock_395292385 2016
File photo.

Nipissing MPP and Parliamentary Leader Vic Fedeli  isn't impressed with today's Liberal budget.

“There is an affordability crisis in Ontario. Hydro rates have skyrocketed, taxes and fees have ballooned, and our provincial debt is the highest of any province or state in the world – compromising the services we all depend on," he wrote in an email.

"The Liberals have had 15 years to take health care, education, and childcare seriously, and it’s only now in an election year that they’re throwing money at problems they helped to create."

Fedeli says Kathleen Wynne will promise the world if it means continuing to cling to power.

"But the people of Ontario know that they can’t be counted on to keep their word. They broke their promise to run a balanced budget, and are plunging Ontario into a massive $6.7 billion deficit, with no plan to return to balance for years to come.

"If the Liberals were to win the next election, everything included in this budget will be added to an already exhaustive list of broken promises."

Ontario's Liberal budget targets nearly every demographic while plunging the province back into deficit, with the books expected to stay in the red for six years.

Party leader Doug Ford wasn't keen either. “Today, Kathleen Wynne continued the re-election spending spree with your money. The Liberals think your vote is for sale, and this budget proves it."

The 2018-2019 budget, tabled Wednesday by Finance Minister Charles Sousa, pumps billions into health care, child care, and support for seniors, though many of the spending promises had been announced by Premier Kathleen Wynne in recent days.

The $158.5-billion fiscal plan, which will likely form the foundation of the Liberals' election platform for the June vote, projects the province will run a $6.7 billion deficit in 2018-2019 and won't return to balance until 2024-2025.

The Canadian Taxpayers Federation is "highly disturbed" by the budget. "There has been much speculation over the past few weeks over the size of the deficit, which was today revealed to stand at $6.7 billion. But it was also confirmed that the government plans to continue to run deficits for six years or two elections from now.

"The finance minister re-committed in November that his government would balance the budget this year. Now we are learning that instead, there will be a $6.7 billion deficit. They didn't just miss their own target, they blew right past it. It's like they aren't even trying," said CTF Ontario Director, Christine Van Geyn.

Even dentists don't like it.

"The Ontario Dental Association has been alerting everyone to the dangers of the serious funding gap in public dental care," it wrote in a news release. "Dentists across the province currently treat about 200,000 kids under the Healthy Smiles Ontario program but there are 500,000 eligible children and youth in the province who deserve to get the dental care and relief they need."

But senior's advocacy group CARP, is generally supportive.

“CARP is pleased that today’s budget shows a needed focus on Ontario seniors.  The investments are significant and broad-ranging. Key investments in the areas of long-term care, housing cost offsets, prescription drug and dental coverage, home care, caregiver, and dementia supports, pension security in retirement and reducing wait times for hospital care will make a real difference in the lives of older Ontarians,” says Laura Tamblyn Watts, CARP’s National Director, Law, Policy and Research.  “However, it is unfortunate that there is nearly no investment in elder abuse and neglect response, a clear priority for older Ontarians.”

The Liberals, who posted their first balanced budget in a decade last year, had vowed to stay in the black through 2019-2020. But two fiscal watchdogs - the province's auditor general and financial accountability officer - had cast doubts on their accounting, with one questioning the government's claims to balance in 2017-2018.

Sousa brushed off suggestions the Liberals were pandering for votes, saying the government made a choice to run a deficit in order to provide what he called much-needed support to Ontarians.

"This is not election-cycle decisions that we're making, these are long-term in scope and they're building upon decisions we have been making all along," he said.

"The responsibility we as government have is to what happens going forward ... This is about protecting people and ensuring that people are better off."

Asked how voters could trust the Liberals to eliminate the deficit after they reneged on their promise to stay in balance, Sousa said the budget includes "a tremendous amount of prudence" in its projections.

"In the last 40 years, there's been eight balanced budgets ... We are looking at the ability to make those investments over time and we will continue to support the people of Ontario."

The province's move back into the red comes as Ontario's unemployment rate, at 5.5. per cent, is at the lowest it's been in 20 years.

The provincial debt, meanwhile, is projected to be $325 billion this year, and paying down interest on the debt is the fourth largest line item in the budget.

The Liberals' fiscal record is likely to come under scrutiny as the party, which has held power for 15 years, fights to stay in government.

While much of the big-ticket spending was announced prior to the budget, the fiscal blueprint builds on a pledge mentioned in last week's throne speech: a drug and dental care program for people without existing coverage. The program, scheduled to launch in summer 2019, is expected to cost $800 over its first two years.

The program will reimburse participants up to 80 per cent of eligible drug and dental expenses per year to a maximum of $400 per single person, $600 per couple, and $700 per family of four.

The budget also includes a new initiative that would provide $750 annually to help seniors aged 75 or older live independently, offsetting the costs of maintaining their homes. The program, starting in 2019-2020, would cost $1 billion over three years.

Newly minted Progressive Conservative Leader Doug Ford said he was skeptical about the Liberals' plans. A Tory government would focus on tackling the provincial debt if elected, he said.

"You can't take care of the most vulnerable people in society when you have billions of dollars in debt," he said. "We're paying a billion a month servicing the debt. Do you know how many families we could help for a billion a month? That's what we have to start focusing on, taking care of our finances."

NDP Leader Andrea Horwath, who earlier this month introduced her party's own dental care plan, called the budget a "meagre" attempt to get votes.

"I really don't accept this suggestion that this budget is a left budget," she said. "Yes, it's left - it left a lot of people out. It left a lot of people out of pharmacare, it left a lot of people out of child care, it left a lot of people out of dental care."

Seniors will get further support as the government's OHIP+ pharmacare program - which currently covers those under 25 - expands to include seniors aged 65 and over, as announced last week.

Another centrepiece is the Liberals' recently announced $2.2 billion plan to provide free child care for preschoolers starting in 2020.

The budget also lays out health-sector spending announced last week, including a base funding increase of $822 million for hospitals.

That comes after Ontario's Financial Accountability Officer warned that a growing and aging population is adding pressure to the health-care system and spending isn't keeping up - a situation that could result in compromised quality of care if left unaddressed.

Despite adding several new high-profile programs, the budget does not include any new major revenue streams.

It introduces a plan to restructure the province's tax brackets and eliminate a surtax paid by filers. The government says that in 2018, 8.6 million individuals would pay roughly the same tax, but 1.8 million people would pay approximately $200 more. About 680,000 people would see a tax reduction of about $130 on average.

The province also says the Ontario Cannabis Retail Corporation, created to manage sales and distribution of recreational pot, expects an $8-million loss in 2017-2018, followed by a $40-million loss in 2018-19, largely due to startup costs.

The Liberals will also hike tobacco taxes again, continuing a three-year plan to increase the price per carton by $10 by 2019-2020.

With files from Shawn Jeffords and Paola Loriggio , The Canadian Press

Jeff Turl

About the Author: Jeff Turl

Jeff is a veteran of the news biz. He's spent a lengthy career in TV, radio, print and online, covering both news and sports. He enjoys free time riding motorcycles and spoiling grandchildren.
Read more

Reader Feedback